How to evaluate medical AI
Use these checklists to evaluate a medical AI tool before your committee signs off. Each guide splits its checklist by what the tool actually does, so an ambient scribe used in cardiology is judged like a scribe, not like an echo algorithm.
Start here
How to evaluate a medical AI tool
The 12 questions that apply to every clinical AI tool: intended use, evidence, FDA status, local validation, workflow, monitoring, data rights, liability and contracts.
Every tool-type checklist covers
- What physicians look for
- What administrators look for
- Evidence to ask for
- How to test it locally
- Red flags
- Questions for the vendor
Checklists by area
Pick the area, then check the line underneath matches what the tool does.
Used across every specialty
Tools any department might buy: ambient scribes, chart summaries and EHR assistants.
Specialty and care-setting clinical tools
Tools that read images, signals or slides, or support decisions in one specialty or care setting, such as the hospital ward and ICU.
- RadiologyIt reads medical images (CT, MRI, X-ray, mammography)5 tool-type checklists
- CardiologyIt analyzes ECGs, echocardiograms or heart-monitor data4 tool-type checklists
- DermatologyIt assesses skin lesions3 tool-type checklists
- PathologyIt analyzes pathology slides4 tool-type checklists
- OncologyIt supports cancer care: radiation contouring, trial matching, treatment decisions3 tool-type checklists
- Neurology & StrokeIt detects stroke or analyzes EEG or brain MRI3 tool-type checklists
- Mental & Behavioral HealthIt supports mental and behavioral health care3 tool-type checklists
- Sepsis & deterioration early warningIt warns of sepsis or deterioration in hospital patients4 tool-type checklists
Business, access and operations
Tools for revenue cycle, patient access and hospital capacity.
- Revenue cycle & prior authorizationIt codes charts, handles prior auth or works denials3 tool-type checklists
- Patient access & triageIt talks to patients: phones, chat, symptom checks, scheduling4 tool-type checklists
- Hospital OperationsIt forecasts capacity, manages beds or schedules staff and ORs4 tool-type checklists
Rules & regulations
Plain-language explainers of the rules buyers ask about most. General information, not advice about a specific tool or patient.
Sources we use
The official databases and standards we check listings against. Use them to confirm a tool's regulatory status, evidence and claims yourself.
Regulatory & safety
Official records for checking the regulatory status and safety of medical AI.
Standards & assurance
Frameworks used to evaluate and govern clinical AI.
Evidence & reporting guidelines
Peer-reviewed reporting standards for AI in medicine.
Literature & databases
Where to find the primary research behind each tool.
Educational information, not medical, legal or regulatory advice. No vendor reviewed, sponsored or edited these guides.