How to evaluate cardiology AI
Cardiology AI is not one kind of product. An algorithm that reads ECGs, software that measures echocardiograms, a model that predicts heart-failure readmission and an ambient scribe used in cardiology clinic each need different questions.
Pick what the tool does below. Each section is a checklist: what physicians and administrators look for, the evidence to ask for, how to test it on your own data, red flags, and questions to put to the vendor.
Last reviewed November 2026 · Independent and vendor-neutral
What does the tool you’re evaluating do?
Jump to the matching checklist. Some answers lead to a different guide.
ECG analysis
Applies if the tool reads ECG tracings, for example to detect arrhythmias or to flag conditions not visible to the eye, such as low ejection fraction, amyloidosis or future atrial fibrillation risk.
Physician looks for
- Whether an AI-ECG finding (low EF, amyloid, AF risk) changes management.
- What the follow-up pathway is: echo capacity, cardiology referral.
- Which ECG machines and software versions it was validated on, and whether that includes yours.
Administrator looks for
- Downstream volume (echo, MRI, clinic visits). This is revenue but also capacity strain.
- Reimbursement. Algorithmic ECG risk assessment has Category III CPT codes 0764T/0765T. Category III codes are tracking codes, and payment isn’t assured.
- Integration with your ECG management system (for example MUSE), echo PACS and the EHR.
- Testing cascades. False positives drive echos, imaging and visits that cost money and can harm patients. Model the cascade before go-live.
- Accountability for misses. If the tool screens every ECG, who is responsible when it misses a finding, and when a flagged result isn’t followed up?
- Performance by sex and body habitus, which affect ECG and echo signals.
IT looks for
- How it connects to your ECG management system (HL7 or vendor interface) and whether results return to the EHR as structured data.
- Where tracings are processed, on your servers or in the vendor’s cloud, and how data leave your network.
Compliance looks for
- Whether the cleared indication covers each finding you plan to act on. Some AI-ECG outputs are not cleared for diagnosis.
- A record showing that each flagged result was reviewed and acted on.
- Ongoing checks of performance by sex, age and race.
Evidence to ask for
- External validation in a population like yours.
- Positive predictive value (PPV) at your expected prevalence.
- A prospective study showing increased diagnosis (with actual confirmatory testing), not only AUC.
Test it locally
- Retrospectively run the tool on 6 to 12 months of your ECGs.
- Estimate how many positives per month it would generate and whether echo capacity can absorb them.
Red flags
- AUC-only claims.
- No plan for who owns a positive result.
- Performance shown only on one vendor’s ECG carts.
Questions to ask the vendor
- “At our prevalence, how many flags per 1,000 ECGs, and how many true positives?”
- “Who receives the result, and what’s the recommended pathway?”
- “Which ECG carts and software versions was it validated on?”
Echocardiography and cardiac imaging
Applies if the tool analyzes echocardiograms, cardiac CT or cardiac MRI, for example by automating measurements, guiding image acquisition or detecting disease.
Physician looks for
- Measurement reproducibility (ejection fraction, chamber size, strain) compared with your sonographers and readers.
- Vendor-neutral support, or a tie to one ultrasound or scanner manufacturer.
- What it does with poor-quality images: flag them, or measure anyway.
- If it guides less experienced sonographers, the training and oversight that requires.
Administrator looks for
- Where results appear: in the echo reporting system and PACS, or a separate viewer.
- Time saved per study, and whether that turns into more studies per day or shorter waits.
- Downstream volume if it detects disease (for example, more cardiac MRI or clinic visits).
- Licensing per machine, per study or per site.
IT looks for
- DICOM connectivity with your echo PACS and reporting system, and whether results return as structured data (for example DICOM SR).
- Whether processing runs on the machine, on your servers or in the vendor’s cloud.
Compliance looks for
- That the clearance covers each measurement and machine model you plan to use.
- A record of which measurements were automated and which a reader edited.
Evidence to ask for
- Agreement with expert readers on studies from several machine models, including technically difficult ones.
- For detection claims, results confirmed by a reference test, not only reader agreement.
Test it locally
- Compare automated measurements against your readers on a few hundred recent studies, including technically difficult ones, and on each machine model you use.
Red flags
- No handling of poor-quality images
- Validation only on high-quality academic studies
- Works on one manufacturer’s machines only, when you run several
Questions to ask the vendor
- “How do your measurements compare with expert readers on machines like ours?”
- “What happens when an image is too poor to measure?”
Risk prediction and finding undiagnosed patients
Applies if the tool uses EHR data to predict outcomes (such as heart-failure readmission) or to find patients who may have untreated disease.
Physician looks for
- How the outcome was defined: by clinical criteria or by billing codes.
- What action is attached to each flag, and who takes it.
Administrator looks for
- How many patients it will flag per month, and whether you have staff to reach them.
- Downstream visits, testing and treatment the flags generate.
IT looks for
- Which EHR data feeds it needs (FHIR, HL7 or bulk extracts) and how often they refresh.
- Where flags appear for staff, and how access is limited to the care team.
Compliance looks for
- If supplied inside a certified EHR, the ONC HTI-1 source attributes. If not, ask for the same information.
- Whether the flag rate differs by race, payer or language for patients with the same true risk.
Evidence to ask for
- Calibration in a population like yours, not only accuracy in ranking patients.
- Evidence that acting on flags improved outcomes, not only that the model predicts well.
Test it locally
- Run it retrospectively on your data and check both accuracy and the number of patients it would surface.
Questions to ask the vendor
- “How many patients per 10,000 would it flag in a population like ours, and how many truly have the condition?”
The predictive-tools guide covers alert thresholds, calibration and silent testing in more detail. Read that guide →
Wearables, ambulatory monitors and device data
Applies if the tool analyzes data from patches, wearables, Holter monitors or pacemakers and defibrillators.
Physician looks for
- Which devices it supports, and whether it is cleared for those inputs.
- The process for urgent findings outside office hours.
- For consumer wearables, how patient-submitted data are verified.
Administrator looks for
- Events sent per patient per month, and who reviews them, and when.
- Staffing for the review queue as enrollment grows.
IT looks for
- How device data reach you: the vendor’s cloud portal, or an HL7 feed into the EHR.
- Security of any patient-facing app, and account management for patients and staff as enrollment grows.
Compliance looks for
- Which devices and inputs the clearance covers.
- Documented response times for urgent findings, and a record of who reviewed each event and when.
Red flags
- No after-hours escalation plan
- Event volume estimates missing
Questions to ask the vendor
- “How many events per patient per month should we expect, and what share need clinician action?”
- “Who handles urgent findings at night and on weekends?”
Further reading
Browse cardiology tools
Every listing shows regulatory status, published evidence and named health-system users where public.